Saturday, July 13, 2013

Kelly's Allegory of the Gym


                "The traditional view serves to protect us from the painful job of thinking"
                                                                                                 ~John Kenneth Galbraith

 
(This blog has been plagiarized…I mean borrowed from Plato’s Allegory of the Cave)

Let’s suppose for a moment that a group of gym people have been together in a gym from birth. They have access to scientific literature, but choose to go with the tradition view from within their cult…I mean group.  
The cultish group… I mean gym people, are positioned so they can only see what their group is pushing…I mean selling. The products they advocate are Herbalife, Advocare, HCG, B-12 injections, shake weights, gut-be-gone, butt blasters,  skin wraps, detox juicers, and many “special workout programs.”

The gym people engage in what appears to us to be a game…cheering wildly and regarding the ones who can explain the efficacy of their product the best as the most reliable. Some even quote scripture as to suggest that God had a hand in their products creation.
This perspective is the only reality that the gym people know… what they are seeing is merely shadows of testimonials that rouse their emotions and expose their ignorance. They are thus conditioned to judge the quality of the product by the skill of the snake oil salesman…I mean orator  

The story continues with one gym person breaking free from the gym. His eyes require time to adjust to the outside light. Once his vision comes into focus he is able to see the numerous scientific texts available regarding nutrition and exercise.

This is a moment of enlightenment.
Once enlightenment occurs, the gym member feels compelled to lead the other members from ignorance toward wisdom.

The gym person would feel a huge responsibility to go back to the others and try to explain that what they were seeing were mere illusions.
Unfortunately….Due to the brain washing…I mean conditioning these people have experienced their whole life, it will be almost impossible to understand what the enlightened gym person is trying to tell them.

In the end…we would rather have comfort than truth.

 
Plato's Allegory of the Cave… “Our sensorial perception of the world creates a false notion of reality. We are tricked into constructing a worldview and believing it to be the real thing. When it comes to understanding the nature of reality we are all shortsighted."